For seventy years, Germany's spies have worked under a rule that sounds noble and plays out as farce. They may watch. They may listen. They may write it all down. And then they must hand the file to someone else and hope that person does something before the bomb goes off.

On Friday, the Bundestag ended that. By 309 votes to 190, with 71 abstentions, MPs passed what interior minister Alexander Dobrindt calls the "reform of the century". His own summary was blunter, as Tagesschau reported: Germany's intelligence services are to stop being mere information services and become "real secret services".

Half of that is overdue. The other half deserves a much harder look than it got.

The half Germany should have done years ago

Start with the BND, the foreign intelligence service. Under the new law it may run covert operations abroad, including sabotage. The BBC lists what that could mean in practice: paralysing the servers of state-sponsored hacker groups, disrupting disinformation networks, cutting the supply chains of weapons aimed at Germany.

If that sounds aggressive, look at the year Germany has had. In August a drone carrying an explosive device was found at Leipzig airport, next to Ukrainian cargo planes. It failed only because the detonator was apparently faulty, and German authorities blame Russia. Dobrindt reels off the rest himself: sabotage on railway lines, cyberattacks on hospitals and public administrations, an attack on Berlin's power supply, espionage in ministries and companies. "Germany is a theatre of operations for terrorism, extremism and foreign powers," he said.

Until this week, Europe's biggest economy answered all of that largely with arrest warrants and with tips from friends. Tagesschau notes that one explicit aim of the reform is to make Germany less dependent on intelligence handed over by allied services. Translation: for years, the country that wants to lead Europe on defence has relied on Washington and others to tell it what was coming. Even Konstantin von Notz, the Greens' deputy parliamentary leader, backed this part, saying it finally lets the BND act "on an equal footing" with its partners.

A state that cannot hit back at a foreign server being used to attack its hospitals is not being principled. It is being a target. On the BND, Berlin got it right, and late.

The half that should worry everybody

Now the other agency. The BfV, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, is Germany's domestic intelligence service. Its brief covers foreign spies on German soil, but also Germans: extremists, Islamists, and political movements it judges a threat to the constitutional order.

Under the new law, the BfV will for the first time be allowed to act rather than just observe. With prior authorisation, its officers may covertly enter a home to install spyware on a phone, manipulate a computer or disable weapons. They may divert data flows, delete or falsify data, and, in the BBC's words, "plant false information on those involved". They get wider rights to monitor encrypted messages, to run online searches, and to use AI analysis and biometric image matching on the internet.

Each power comes with a reason that sounds sensible. Disarming a bomb before it explodes is obviously good. Arrests and open searches stay with the police. A panel of former judges is to check certain measures in advance.

But step back and read the list again: secret entry into homes, falsified data, deliberate misinformation, in the hands of the agency that also classifies which domestic groups count as enemies of the constitution. That is not a technical upgrade. It is a change in what kind of state Germany is willing to be at home.

The clause that gives the game away

Buried in the reform is a detail that tells you who Berlin is really nervous about. According to Tagesschau, the federal BfV may now limit its cooperation with individual state intelligence offices, a provision written in response to the AfD's election win in Saxony-Anhalt.

You can see the logic. A state government led by a party the security services distrust would control its own regional intelligence office. Nobody in Berlin wants secrets flowing there. But notice what has happened. A law sold as a shield against Moscow, Beijing and Tehran also carries a mechanism designed around the outcome of a German election. In the same law, the domestic agency is handed tools to falsify data and plant misinformation.

Dobrindt, a conservative from the CSU, says it is "madness" to call this a new secret police. He may well mean it, and today's ministers may well use these powers with restraint. But laws outlive ministers. The relevant question is not what Dobrindt will do with a BfV that can quietly enter a flat. It is what his successor will do, in a decade, with a parliament and a mood nobody can predict.

Strong abroad, restrained at home

That is the old conservative instinct, and it is worth recovering: a state should be hard on its enemies and modest towards its own citizens. This law gets the first half right and gets careless with the second. Von Notz put it memorably, accusing the government of using the pressure on the BND "to take one decisive swig too many from the bottle" on the domestic side.

The objections have not come only from the usual suspects. The Left's Clara Bünger called the law "a monster" and warned that the separation of police and secret service, a lesson of the Nazi era, is being worn down. The AfD's Alice Weidel called it an attack on the rule of law. Both voted against. When a law manages to unite the far left and the hard right in opposition, it does not prove the law is wise. But it should remind the centre that it is building powers its opponents may one day inherit.

There was a better way, and there still is. Pass the BND powers, because the threat is real and the drones are not hypothetical. Put the domestic powers on a short leash: a firm sunset clause that forces parliament to renew them after a few years, published annual figures on how often homes were entered and data falsified, and a full right for citizens to be told afterwards that they were targeted. Critics are expected to take the law to the Federal Constitutional Court anyway. Karlsruhe has a chance to draw exactly that line.

Germany needed spies who could hit back at Putin. It now has them. Above the door of the building where this law was passed, carved in stone, are the words "Dem deutschen Volke", to the German people. The test of this reform is whether the new powers are aimed outward, at the people attacking Germany, or end up pointed at the people that inscription is for.