For months, Europe's governments have had one complaint about the Ukraine peace talks: nobody asked them. On Thursday, they got their wish. After an afternoon with Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin, Steve Witkoff announced that a new round of talks had been agreed and that "the Europeans will join at the next meeting", as the Guardian reported, quoting Reuters.
Champagne in Dublin, then? Not quite. Because the same afternoon, the Kremlin made clear what it wants to talk to Europe about. Not Ukraine. Europe.
The agenda nobody in Dublin wanted
Putin's aide Yuri Ushakov said Moscow had told the Americans that NATO could not expand any further, and that he hoped Europe would support talks on "a new European security architecture". The day before, Russia's chief negotiator Vladimir Medinsky had explained the idea in Abu Dhabi with his usual delicacy. "The whole organism is ailing, and Ukraine was just a place where an abscess has burst," he said, according to Euronews. "A simple adhesive bandage will not suffice."
Translate the medical metaphor and you get an old demand in a new coat. In December 2021, weeks before the full-scale invasion, Moscow sent the West draft treaties asking NATO to pull its forces back to where they stood in 1997, before Poland, the Baltic states and the rest of central and eastern Europe joined. NATO said no. Finland and Sweden answered by joining. Now the same list is back, this time with an American envoy carrying it between capitals.
Meanwhile Putin used the televised part of his meeting to say, per AFP, that there is "only one line of demarcation: the state border", by which he means Russia's claimed border, including four Ukrainian regions his army does not fully hold. Foreign peacekeepers in Ukraine, the backbone of Europe's planned guarantees for Kyiv, would be a "legitimate target" and "the continuation of war". That is the opening position of the man Europe has just been invited to sit across from.
"We already have an architecture"
To be fair to Europe's leaders, they saw the trap. Estonia's prime minister Kristen Michal called it exactly that. Emmanuel Macron said Europeans "will be the ones to define and decide" their own security. Kaja Kallas, the EU's foreign policy chief, had the sharpest line on sequencing: first a ceasefire, then a peace settlement, and only at the very end any talk about Europe's security. She is right, and that order should be carved into the door of whatever room these talks end up in.
Then Kallas added a second argument, and this is where it gets uncomfortable. "We already have a European security architecture in place," she said, citing the 1975 Helsinki Final Act, the 1990 Charter of Paris and the 1994 Budapest Memorandum. "The problem is that Russia is not keeping to those agreements."
Read that list again. The Budapest Memorandum is the document in which Ukraine gave up the nuclear weapons on its soil in return for assurances, from Russia among others, that its borders would be respected. It is not a pillar of Europe's security. It is the crime scene. Helsinki promised that frontiers in Europe would not be changed by force. The Charter of Paris promised a "new era of democracy, peace and unity". All three are still in place, in the sense that the paper has not been shredded. Russia simply walked through them.
António Costa, the European Council president, said there is "no need to reinvent the wheel". Fine. But if your answer to a man who wants to redraw the map is a stack of agreements he has already torn up, you are not defending an architecture. You are defending the wallpaper.
The real architecture has soldiers in it
Here is what actually keeps Tallinn, Vilnius and Warsaw safe tonight: NATO's Article 5, American and European troops on the ground in the east, and the credible belief in Moscow that an attack on them would be answered. That is the architecture. Everything else is the guided tour.
Which is why the Kremlin's demand matters so much more than the row in Dublin over who should speak for Europe, a row that, as Rapporteur put it, had leaders unable to agree even on whether it was spoiling the mood. Friedrich Merz wants the E3 of Germany, France and Britain at the table. Giorgia Meloni wants an EU envoy and a decision this year. Luxembourg's Luc Frieden cheerfully spoke for all three Benelux countries, because the Belgian and Dutch leaders were too busy with crises at home. Russia, for its part, says it will happily talk to Europe as soon as Europe names someone to talk to.
Albania's Edi Rama, not an EU member, said the quiet part aloud: "Europe has outsourced its diplomacy to Donald Trump. Europe has to realise that this mistake has a price." The price is now on the table. When you let others write the agenda, you should not be surprised to find yourself on it.
What Europe should actually bring
Macron said something sensible too: "the content determines the format". So here is some content.
First, a line that is not for sale. NATO's membership and the presence of allied troops on the eastern flank are not a topic for talks with the country that invaded its neighbour. Not at stage three, not ever. Say it before the next meeting, in writing, from every capital, so no envoy can pretend to have misheard.
Second, Kallas's sequence, enforced. Ukraine first. A ceasefire and a settlement that leave Kyiv able to defend itself. Only then, and only from a position of strength, a conversation about arms control or confidence-building, the kind of thing the Cold War actually produced when the West negotiated with tanks behind it rather than treaties in front of it.
Third, the guarantee Europe keeps promising Kyiv has to be real. Putin has said foreign troops in Ukraine would be targets. A reassurance force that dissolves the moment he says so was never a reassurance.
And fourth, the boring bit: the capacity to back any of this up. On the same day, Zelenskyy complained that the military version of Starlink was being throttled again over Ukraine. Europe's security still runs, in part, on systems Europe does not control.
Zelenskyy warned leaders in Dublin that the talks were turning into "some kind of new security framework between Europe and Russia" and told them to "pay attention". Europe spent the autumn demanding a seat. It has one now. The question is whether it walks in as a party to the negotiation, or as the subject of it.