Every online shopper knows the trick. "Only 1 left!" "5 other people are looking at this room!" A clock ticks down in red. You panic, you click, and the next morning the same last room is somehow still available.
On Wednesday the European Commission declared war on all of it. Its new Digital Fairness Act would ban fake scarcity, shame buttons that make you click "I don't like good deals" to unsubscribe, pre-ticked boxes, subscriptions you can join in one tap and leave in twelve, and loot boxes sold to children. Consumer commissioner Michael McGrath called it "the most significant reform of EU consumer protection rules in more than 20 years".
Most of that is good news, and this paper is happy to say so. Subscription traps are a racket. A right to reach a human being instead of a chatbot is the kind of thing conservatives used to call common decency. If Brussels stopped there, we would be writing a short, grumpy-but-grateful column.
It did not stop there.
A rulebook that is never sold out
Listen to how Executive Vice-President Henna Virkkunen introduced the package. Europe, she said, already enforces the Digital Services Act, the Digital Markets Act and the AI Act, and has just proposed an EU KIDS Act. The new law "will not duplicate this", she promised. "It will reinforce our rulebook."
That is the Brussels method in one sentence. When the last rule has not fixed the problem, the answer is never to ask why. It is to add another layer on top and call the pile a foundation. Germany's Tagesschau reports that business groups are asking the obvious question: could all of this not be handled with the laws already on the books?
They have a point. Lying to shoppers that an offer is about to vanish has been on the EU's blacklist of practices banned "in all circumstances" since 2005. It is point 7 of Annex I of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. The problem with the red countdown clock was never a missing law. It was that nobody enforced the one we had.
The Commission half admits this. Its own press release says the network of national consumer authorities has run more than 30 coordinated actions since 2020, across a market of 450 million people.
The real headline is the new police force
Which brings us to the part of the package that got less airtime than the influencers: the revision of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation.
Today the Commission cannot enforce consumer law itself. Under the proposal it could open its own investigations into any non-SME firm whose practice touches two-thirds of member states and two-thirds of the EU's population, and fine it up to 6% of worldwide turnover. Once Brussels opens a case, national authorities must stop investigating the same one.
At the same time, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which every country could fit to its own legal system, becomes a Regulation that applies directly in all 27. The Commission sells this as less fragmentation, and for a company selling in ten countries it may well be simpler. But be clear about what is happening. Power is moving from national regulators, answerable to national parliaments, to a Commission that will now write the rule, police it and set the fine.
McGrath insists it will only be "a relatively small number of cases". Every new Brussels power arrives with that promise attached.
Three numbers and one slogan
The Commission says the package should save consumers "up to €13.7 billion a year". McGrath told reporters that consumers are losing €10.3 billion a year. Tagesschau, citing the Commission, puts last year's damage at around €8 billion. The figures may measure different things, but the Commission did not explain the gap. A law that promises to save you more than you are said to be losing deserves the same scepticism Brussels wants you to apply to "Only 1 left!".
Then there is the slogan. "We are not making it harder to do business," McGrath said. "We are making it harder to do business unfairly." It is a good line. The Financial Times had a less flattering one on Wednesday morning: "Brussels to unveil new Big Tech rules despite vow to slash red tape." On 19 November last year, Virkkunen and McGrath stood at the same Commission podium to present a "digital omnibus" trimming their own GDPR and AI rules, and Virkkunen promised to "get rid of regulatory 'clutter'". Fifty-one weeks later, the same two are back with the clutter's next instalment.
And it will only grow
The proposal is the moderate version. The Rapporteur news site reports that four MEPs from the EPP, S&D, Renew and the Greens had already urged an outright ban on dynamic pricing. Socialist and Green MEPs want tougher rules on addictive design for adults, not just an off switch. The digital rights group EDRi says an opt-out "should not automatically be considered sufficient". The law is far more likely to grow in Parliament than to shrink. And according to Tagesschau it may not bind anyone until 2029, by which time the tricks it targets will have moved on.
A better deal for shoppers
There is a simpler route, and it is cheaper for everyone.
First, enforce the blacklist Europe already has. Fake countdowns have been illegal for over 20 years. Give national authorities the staff to prove it, and publish the names of the offenders.
Second, keep the police national. If a giant platform cheats in 20 countries, let those regulators act together, as the law already allows, instead of handing Brussels a new 6% weapon it will want to use.
Third, take McGrath at his word. He wants every automatic renewal to be "a conscious choice, not a forgotten obligation". Excellent principle. Put a sunset clause in the Digital Fairness Act and make Parliament renew it on purpose in ten years.
Europe's shoppers deserve honest checkouts. They also deserve a lawmaker that does not treat its own supply of new rules as permanently in stock.