On Friday morning Downing Street put out a statement of enviable clarity. "The deal is done – negotiations have concluded," a spokesperson for Andy Burnham said, as the Guardian's live blog recorded. Both sides, it added, "have agreed when these will come into force".

Now read the other side's paper. A statement from the Council and the Commission, seen by the Guardian, says the four agreements "form a package". A Council text seen by Rapporteur is blunter still: adoption of the carbon-market, food and youth agreements "shall not precede the conclusion of the negotiations on the supplementing agreement providing for equal treatment on tuition fees".

Done, then. Just not adopted. Not until Britain settles a bill that was supposed to have been parked for six months.

"We are not taking anyone hostage"

A senior EU official, speaking to Rapporteur, put it with a straight face: "We have not yet reached an agreement on tuition fees, and we have given ourselves six months to reach that agreement... We are not taking anyone hostage here."

Nobody said hostage, of course. That is rather the clue. Consider the sequence. This week, the Guardian reports, Brussels agreed to defer the fee question by six months, a move that handed London some leverage in parallel talks about being included in the EU's "Made in Europe" supply-chain law. On Friday morning, EU sources said, the whole package was made conditional on fees, which is designed to neutralise that leverage. The Guardian's own snap analysis called it "a serious chess game". Chess, that is, in which one player owns the board.

We flagged the shape of this on 23 October: the demand was moved, not dropped. What is new is that it is now in writing, with a clock on it.

What "done" actually buys

Take the calendar. The draft joint statement of 17 November, which went to EU ambassadors and was obtained by Agence Europe, says the food agreement is to apply "from 1 March 2028". The youth scheme, which will let 100,000 young people each way live abroad for up to three years, is promised "no later than January 2030", according to Euronews and Rapporteur. Erasmus+ is the quick one: Britain rejoins on 1 January 2027, Euronews notes.

So the first consignment of British food crosses without a vet's certificate some 15 months from now, if everything holds. The youth scheme opens in 2030 at the latest, which is a deadline, not a start date. Burnham told business leaders on Friday that Treasury analysis says the deal is worth up to 0.5% of GDP and called it "the single biggest growth intervention in this Parliament". The Guardian had earlier put the figure at 0.4%. The youth scheme, meanwhile, is promised for a date after the next general election is due.

None of that makes the deal worthless. The government says easier food exports will eventually be worth £5.1bn a year, as the Guardian reported in early November, and farmers and exporters who lost business when the checks came in have every reason to want it. The BBC points out that it would also largely end the port checks on food moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland, a real prize for unionists and shoppers alike. But the BBC's Chris Mason put the whole thing in one sentence: "the biggest set of changes with Brussels since Brexit and yet also a series of tweaks".

A seat at the table, or near it

The price is the part that should interest anyone who voted to leave. The BBC describes the food deal as Switzerland's: follow EU rules "almost to the letter", under "dynamic alignment", with oversight from the European Court of Justice, and "without much say in setting those rules".

Britain asked for a vote on some of the lawmaking. France, by all accounts, said no, and London gave way. According to Rapporteur, UK representatives may be invited as observers to meetings relevant to food legislation, without voting powers. One EU diplomat told the Guardian that Britain will have a "voice" but will "not be in the room" when laws are drafted.

An observer's chair at a table that sets your rules is a wonderful thing to put on a Treasury slide and a strange thing to call taking back control. The point is not that Britain should refuse. The point is that nobody involved can now pretend it is a partnership of equals, and the hand on the switch is in Brussels.

The one thing that starts now is a conversation

There is one item in the draft statement that needs no ratification and no 2028. Paragraph 68 of the draft commits the EU and the UK to a "Structured Dialogue" on migration which covers, among other things, "returns to third countries".

It is the first time the two sides have formally agreed to talk about sending rejected asylum seekers to hubs outside Europe, the Guardian reports. Whitehall sources told it that London is now open to the Rwanda option, which Keir Starmer's government rejected, and a Home Office spokesperson said the government has "consistently made clear that we support the principle of returns hubs". This is the same Rwanda that cost Britain £700m, in the Guardian's figure, and that Brussels once called a bad idea. Last week five EU governments announced their own hub there, as we reported.

The irony is almost too tidy. The only part of the reset that moves immediately is the part where both sides sit down to talk. Everything with a legal text, a customs form or a price tag waits for 2028, 2030 or the next deal. A dialogue costs nothing and binds nobody. It is also, admittedly, the one subject on which voters on both sides of the Channel have been asking for results since 2016.

The fair objection

The EU's defenders have a case, and it deserves its hearing. The Union's position is that equal treatment for students is a principle, not a trinket: before Brexit, EU students paid the same as home students at British universities, and Euronews cites Oxford's Migration Observatory for a 57% fall in EU students starting courses between 2020/21 and 2023/24. Brussels thinks that makes the relationship "poorer", in the words of an EU official. A package is a package; nobody wants to sign the sweeteners and lose the sour bit.

It is also true that the clock is for both sides. The Guardian's analysis points out that the link creates a hard political deadline in six months which adds urgency to settle it. Both governments want the deals. The EU is not wrong to use the leverage it has, only wrong to dress it as generosity.

What happens next

Burnham's spokesperson said that after the summit, talks will start on the "realistic options" for a longer-term relationship, with no more incremental resets. Nigel Farage, in Brussels, called the whole exercise a "betrayal" and predicted the debate would "very very soon" become one about rejoining. The prime minister, for his part, told the Guardian last month he is "not proposing rejoining [the EU] in this parliament".

That is the tell. A reset that begins in 2028, rests on a tuition-fee clause and ends with the question "rejoin or stay out" is not the end of a negotiation. It is the opening position of the next one, with a better seat for the EU. Britain should pocket the food deal if the price is fair. But "done" is a word for contracts that are in force. This one is not. Ask for the dates before you applaud the photograph.