There is a particular genre of Brussels arithmetic in which you ask for €2 trillion, settle for €1.78 trillion, and announce that you have saved €204 billion. On Saturday morning António Costa, President of the European Council, performed it live.
His new "nego box", Brussels-speak for a negotiating framework, for the EU's 2028-2034 budget trims the Commission's original blueprint by 10.2 per cent, according to Politico. That is deeper than Cyprus offered in June (2 per cent) and deeper than Ireland offered in October (8 per cent). Costa called it "a realistic budget that addresses our new priorities while preserving our established policies".
Then Friedrich Merz, whose country writes the biggest cheque, read the small print. "An EU budget that simultaneously grows by over 40% is not appropriate in these times," the German chancellor said, as quoted by Rapporteur.
A cut that grows. Welcome to the seven-year budget.
A diet measured against a banquet
The trick is in the baseline. Every saving Costa announced is measured against what the Commission asked for in July 2025, not against what the EU spends today. As Euronews puts it plainly, the Commission's proposal was already higher than the current budget, "so despite the cuts most funding programmes would still see an increase compared with the ongoing MFF". The same report notes that the cut looks more modest still once you strip out inflation.
If a household planned a new kitchen, a second car and a cruise, then dropped the cruise, nobody would call that austerity. In Brussels it gets a press conference.
And look at what got dropped. Competitiveness and defence, the "new priorities" every summit communiqué has been worshipping since the Draghi report, lose €95.5bn, or 16 per cent. Global Europe, the external-action pot, loses 21 per cent. Farming and cohesion, meanwhile, give up only about 5 per cent between them. "It seems like Santa Claus came early this year for the French," one EU diplomat told Rapporteur. Paris, naturally, says it is "very disappointing" and wants more for the Common Agricultural Policy.
So the future gets cut and the past gets protected. That is not a reform. It is a budget arranged around who shouts loudest.
The €10bn that isn't a saving
Here is the line that should make any finance minister put down his coffee. Part of the headline saving does not come from spending less at all. Costa proposes to reduce repayments on NextGenerationEU, the Covid-era joint debt, by €10bn over 2028-2034. Politico counts that €10bn among the savings.
Repayment still runs until 2058, an EU official said; only its "profile" changes. "We slightly change the way the capital is paid," the official told reporters, without saying what that means for rolling old debt into new debt.
Translation: the bill was due in 2028, and part of it will now be due later. Postponing a debt is many things. A saving is not one of them. Euronews drily notes that the frugals "are unlikely to consider" it a reduction. They are right. When a government does this, we call it creative accounting. When Brussels does it, we call it a compromise.
This is the same joint debt that Brussels swore would be a one-off. It is turning out to be a very relaxed one-off.
And to keep you calm, a new tax
How do you keep the spending high while telling capitals their contributions will barely move? Costa's answer is in his own words: "With this proposal we have managed to come very close to the current level of national contributions." The gap is filled by what Brussels calls a "balanced basket of new own resources", worth around €64bn a year, according to Euronews.
The headline item is a 3 per cent levy on the turnover, not the profit, of large digital companies: online advertising, digital intermediation and the monetisation of user data, for firms with more than €750m in global and €50m in EU digital turnover. It replaces the Commission's corporate levy, CORE, which capitals buried because it clashed with the EU's own competitiveness agenda. Around it sit a new, phased-in tobacco resource, higher charges on plastic and electronic waste, all of the carbon-border levy's revenue, and a phased-in slice of emissions-trading revenue.
Brussels used to hold back on taxing Big Tech for fear of retaliation from Washington. Politico reports that the Republicans' bruising defeat in this month's midterms "created an opening". So the EU's fiscal strategy now includes reading American election results and deciding the coast is clear.
Will Google and Meta pay it? Formally, yes. In practice, history is not encouraging. When France brought in its own 3 per cent digital services tax in 2019, Amazon told sellers on Amazon.fr it would raise its referral fees by 3 per cent to "reflect this additional cost", as Tax Notes and CNN reported at the time. A levy aimed at California has a habit of landing on the small seller in Lyon, the travel agent in Bruges, the advertiser in Graz.
There is also a matter of principle. A tax collected for the Union and sent straight to the Union's budget is a step towards a fiscal power that no European voter has ever been asked to grant. The digital levy alone is put at about €5bn a year, roughly what the Commission estimated. The Parliament, which wanted a 5 per cent rate on a wider range of services, dreams of up to €25bn. Once the pipe is laid, guess which way the flow will go.
The fair objection
Defenders will say the comparison is unfair. Even Poland's EU-affairs deputy minister, Ignacy Niemczycki, who wants more farm and cohesion money for Warsaw, not less, says that "relatively speaking, the EU budget is smaller than the current one", without spelling out the yardstick. Repaying the Covid debt, they add, is a fixed cost nobody can wish away, and every euro raised from Big Tech is a euro national treasuries do not have to send.
All true, as far as it goes. But it proves the critics' point. If the debt is unavoidable, then spreading it thinner is not a saving. If the budget is "smaller" only relative to a growing economy, then the "€204bn cut" is a slogan, not a number. And if new EU taxes are needed to keep contributions "reasonable", then what is actually being cut is the honesty of the debate.
The Netherlands' finance minister, Eelco Heinen, put the alternative in one line: "The choice is simple: the EU budget needs to shrink, or our national rebate needs to increase." The European Parliament, through budget negotiator Siegfried Mureșan, wants the opposite: it calls Costa's draft "unacceptable" because the cuts "take the negotiations backwards". MEPs want the Commission's €2tn plus 10 per cent. Somewhere between those two positions lies the taxpayer, who was not invited.
What leaders should ask on Thursday
The 27 meet in Brussels on Thursday for a special summit, and every new own resource needs unanimity, then approval in each member state under its own constitutional rules. That gives every capital a veto, and every voter, through their parliament, a say. Three demands would make the talks more honest.
First, publish every heading against today's budget, in today's prices, next to the "cut" against the Commission's wish list. Let voters see the 40 per cent for themselves.
Second, take the €10bn debt deferral out of the savings column and put it where it belongs: in a line marked "postponed".
Third, if Brussels wants its own tax, let national parliaments debate it as one, out loud, rather than smuggle it through as an accounting basket. Costa's earlier rush to close the deal before France and Italy vote suggests he would rather they didn't.
A real cut is when you spend less than last time. Everything else is a menu with the prices hidden. On Thursday, Europe's leaders should ask to see the bill.